Chicago Jibarito (Plantain Sandwich)
No bread. The plantain IS the bread. Genius accident from a Chicago neighborhood.
Why this dish belongs to Chicago
The jibarito is Chicago's gift to American sandwich-cuisine, invented at Borinquen Restaurant in Humboldt Park (Chicago's Puerto Rican neighborhood) in 1996. The story: owner Juan 'Pete' Figueroa was experimenting with using twice-fried green plantains as a sandwich substitute, inspired by Caribbean recipes and his own desire for a heartier alternative to bread. The dish caught on with the Chicago Puerto Rican community, then spread to other Caribbean-American neighborhoods (NYC, Miami), but Chicago is universally credited as the birthplace. The plantains are 'tostones' (twice-fried, mashed flat) used as the bread; fillings are typically thin-sliced steak (sirloin) marinated with garlic, plus lettuce, tomato, and a garlic mayo (mayo + minced garlic + olive oil). Jibarito Stop, Coco's, La Parada, and Borinquen Restaurant all serve canonical versions. The dish is technically gluten-free (plantain instead of bread), making it a popular alternative for celiac diners. Eaten with both hands, messy, with jus dripping. The name 'jibarito' is a Puerto Rican term for a country/farm dweller.
Method · 10 steps
- 1
Marinate the steak: combine sliced steak with minced garlic, olive oil, salt, pepper, paprika, cumin, and oregano. Toss to coat. Refrigerate at least 30 minutes (or up to 4 hours).
- 2
Make the garlic mayo: stir together mayo, minced garlic, olive oil, and lemon juice in a small bowl. Refrigerate.
- 3
Peel the plantains: cut off both ends. Score the skin lengthwise in 4 places (don't go through the flesh). Peel the strips off (use a paring knife under the skin if it's stubborn).
- 4
Cut each peeled plantain in half horizontally — you'll have 8 plantain pieces total, 4 inches long each.
- 5
First fry: heat 2 inches of vegetable oil in a Dutch oven to 350°F. Fry plantain pieces 4–5 minutes until pale yellow and beginning to get tender. Remove with a slotted spoon to a paper-towel-lined plate.
- 6
Smash the plantains: while still warm, place each plantain piece between two sheets of parchment paper. Smash with the bottom of a heavy skillet (or a tostonera if you have one) until 1/4 inch thick. They should be flat ovals.
- 7
Second fry: heat the oil to 375°F. Fry the smashed plantains in batches 2 minutes per side until golden brown and crispy. Drain on paper towels. Sprinkle with salt while hot.
- 8
Cook the steak: heat a cast iron skillet over high heat until smoking. Add steak slices in batches; cook 1-2 minutes per side until just past medium-rare. Don't overcook — thin sliced cooks fast.
- 9
Build: place a fried plantain piece on a plate. Spread garlic mayo. Layer lettuce, tomato slices (salt and pepper them), and 4 oz of steak. Top with another fried plantain piece.
- 10
Press gently to compact. Cut diagonally if you want to be fancy. Serve immediately with extra mayo on the side.
Chef's notes
- →Green plantains are essential. They MUST be fully green, no yellow spots. Yellow plantains are sweet and won't fry properly. If you can only find yellow, they'll turn into maduros (sweet plantains), which is a different dish.
- →The two-fry technique is non-negotiable. First fry softens; second fry crisps. Skipping a fry = mushy or rubbery plantain.
- →Smash gently while warm. Cold plantains crack instead of flattening. If you don't have a tostonera, the bottom of a heavy skillet works fine.
- →Use thin-sliced steak. Thick steak takes too long to cook in the time the plantain stays crisp. Sirloin tip or skirt steak sliced 1/4 inch is right.
- →Eat immediately. Jibaritos go from perfect to soggy fast (the plantain absorbs juice). Serve as soon as built.
Storage
Don't store assembled. Fried plantains keep 4 hours at room temperature; reheat in 400°F oven for 5 minutes to re-crisp. Steak keeps 3 days separately. Build to order.
Frequently asked
- Where can I find green plantains?
- Most major supermarkets carry green plantains in the produce section near bananas — sometimes labeled 'plantains' or 'plátanos.' Hispanic or Caribbean markets always have them. Pick ones that are fully green, firm, with intact skin. Yellow = wrong; ripe plantains can't be made into tostones.
- Can I sub yellow plantains?
- No — yellow (ripe) plantains will turn into maduros (sweet caramelized plantains) when fried, which is a different and excellent dish but doesn't work as a sandwich bread. The sweetness is wrong; the texture is wrong. Only green works.
- What other fillings work in a jibarito?
- Pulled pork (Cuban-style mojo pork is excellent), chicken (jerked or marinated), shrimp with garlic. The Borinquen restaurant offers chicken and pork variations. Steak is most common; experiment freely.
- Is jibarito actually Puerto Rican or Chicago?
- It's Chicago-Puerto Rican — invented in Chicago by a Puerto Rican chef using Caribbean techniques. The dish doesn't exist in Puerto Rico (where green plantains are eaten as tostones, but not used as sandwich bread). It's a Chicago Puerto Rican-American hybrid creation.
- Is this gluten-free?
- Yes — by design, jibarito is naturally gluten-free since plantain replaces bread. Many Chicago restaurants serve it specifically as a celiac-friendly option. Just verify the marinade and any sauces don't contain gluten.
Save recipes, plan meals, cook smarter
Get new recipes and seasonal meal plans straight to your inbox — no spam, unsubscribe any time.