Chicago Italian Beef
'Wet,' 'dry,' or 'dipped' — three orders, all correct. Chicago's signature sandwich.
Why this dish belongs to Chicago
The Italian beef sandwich is Chicago's contribution to the American sandwich pantheon, born in Italian-American immigrant communities of the Near West Side in the 1930s. The story (apocryphal but persistent): immigrant families couldn't afford big roasts so they sliced thin and stretched the meat by simmering in seasoned broth, served piled on Italian bread to feed crowds at Italian-American weddings — hence 'Italian beef.' Al's #1 Italian Beef opened in 1938 and is the canonical version; Mr. Beef on Orleans, Portillo's (chain), and Johnnie's Beef in Elmwood Park all serve definitive ones. The beef is top round or sirloin tip, slow-roasted with garlic, oregano, and Italian herbs, then sliced paper-thin against the grain and held warm in seasoned beef stock (the 'gravy' or 'jus'). Built on a French-bread Italian roll. Dressed with either sweet bell peppers (the 'sweet' option) or spicy giardiniera (pickled vegetables). Ordered 'dipped' (whole sandwich submerged in jus before serving — wettest), 'wet' (beef extra-saucy, bun unsmashed), or 'dry' (less jus). Eaten leaning forward over a paper-lined tray; messy is correct.
Method · 13 steps
- 1
Preheat oven to 350°F.
- 2
Pat the roast dry. Mix oregano, basil, crushed fennel, red pepper flakes, salt, and pepper in a bowl. Rub all over the roast.
- 3
Heat olive oil in a Dutch oven over high heat. Sear the roast on all sides until deeply browned, about 12 minutes total.
- 4
Remove the roast. Add smashed garlic to the pot and cook 1 minute until fragrant.
- 5
Pour in beef stock, water, tomato sauce, Italian seasoning, and bay leaf. Whisk to combine, scraping up brown bits.
- 6
Return the roast to the pot. Bring to a simmer.
- 7
Cover and transfer to the 350°F oven. Roast 2.5 hours, turning the roast once halfway through. The meat should be fork-tender but still slice-able.
- 8
Remove the roast from the pot. Let cool to room temperature, then refrigerate at least 2 hours (or overnight) — this firms up the meat for thin slicing.
- 9
Strain the cooking liquid (the 'jus') through a fine-mesh sieve. Discard solids. Refrigerate the jus separately.
- 10
Slice the chilled roast against the grain into paper-thin slices using a sharp slicing knife (or have your butcher slice it on their deli slicer if you don't have a sharp slicer at home).
- 11
To serve: heat the jus in a large pot until simmering. Add the sliced beef and warm gently — DON'T boil. The beef should be hot and saucy after 3–4 minutes.
- 12
Slice each Italian roll horizontally, hinge open. Pile generously with warm beef (about 6 oz per sandwich), letting the jus soak into the bread. Top with sweet peppers OR hot giardiniera (your call). Dip the whole assembled sandwich in jus for 'dipped' style.
- 13
Serve immediately on a paper-lined tray. Eat leaning forward.
Chef's notes
- →Sliced thin is the entire concept. If you can't slice paper-thin at home, ask your butcher to slice the cooled roast on their deli slicer. Worth the extra trip.
- →The jus is the second half of the dish. Don't underseason it — taste before serving and add salt and Italian seasoning as needed.
- →Hot giardiniera is the Chicago move. It's a pickled mix of cauliflower, carrots, celery, peppers, olives in oil. Marconi and Vienna are the Chicago brands; available widely.
- →Italian rolls (Turano, Gonnella) are sturdier than French rolls — they hold up to the jus dipping. French rolls work but get soggier.
- →Make the beef ahead. Roast and cool the day before; slice and warm in jus the day of serving. The flavor improves overnight.
Storage
Refrigerate roast (sliced or whole) up to 4 days; freezes 2 months in jus. Reheat slices gently in jus over low heat. Don't microwave; texture suffers.
Frequently asked
- What's giardiniera?
- An Italian-American pickled vegetable mix: cauliflower, carrots, celery, peppers, olives, in oil and vinegar. The Chicago version is hot (with hot peppers) and oily. Marconi and Vienna are the Chicago brands. Eaten on Italian beef, on pizza, on antipasto plates.
- Sweet vs hot — which one to order?
- Sweet (sautéed bell peppers) is mild and pairs well with the savory beef. Hot (giardiniera) is spicy, salty, and pickled — adds complexity. Locals split about 60/40 hot/sweet. First-timers should try sweet; spice-tolerant should jump to hot.
- What does 'dipped' mean?
- After assembly, the entire sandwich (with bread) is briefly submerged in the jus before being placed on the tray. The bun absorbs the jus and becomes saucy. 'Dry' = no extra dipping. 'Wet' = lots of jus on the beef but bread not dipped. 'Dipped' is wettest and eatable only with fork-and-knife.
- Italian beef vs French dip?
- Italian beef is Chicago: thin-sliced beef in seasoned jus, on Italian roll, with peppers/giardiniera. French dip is LA's Philippe's (1908): sliced rare beef on French roll, with horseradish, jus served on the side for dipping. Different sandwiches; both excellent.
- Can I use a slow cooker?
- Yes — sear the roast first in a skillet, transfer to slow cooker with the jus ingredients, cook on low 8 hours. Slightly different texture (meat falls apart easier — pot roast vs roast beef) but still excellent. Authentic Italian beef is roasted, but slow cooker gives a serviceable version.
Save recipes, plan meals, cook smarter
Get new recipes and seasonal meal plans straight to your inbox — no spam, unsubscribe any time.